Skip to main content

ImageFeatured

La Jornada, Albuquerque Museum

La Jornada, Albuquerque Museum
This is a portion of a large group representing Spanish colonizers on the trail north to New Mexico. A controversial subject!

Add Comment

Comments (1)

Newest · Oldest · Popular

UPDATE

When I posted this image two years ago, and described it as 'a controversial subject,' that was really a faint reaction to a serious issue. I wish now I had gone deeper into it, especially now that the statue's meaning and its removal have become big news.

Here's a bit of background. The statue came about through the efforts of the New Mexican Hispanic Culture Preservation League about twenty years ago. The League wanted to "represent our deep desire to acknowledge our Spanish Colonial roots." That's been an issue in New Mexico since the arrival of "Americans" in 1848, after the Mexican War took the territory from Mexico.

But underneath that history is the 16th conquest of the native peoples of New Mexico, especially the Pueblos, by those same "Spanish Colonial" forces represented in the statues of colonizers led by Juan de Oñate. Oñate himself seems a strange figure to commemorate; he was so known in his own time for cruelty (he ordered the execution of 800 members of the Acoma Pueblo, routinely had prisoners' feet cut off and more) that the Spanish government convicted him of cruelty and banished him.

And so, we see how complex history is: facts do not always add up to truth. To the still active and organized Pueblos the arrival of Oñate is tragedy; to the also-large and organized New Mexicans of Spanish colonial descent, it is triumph and a rebuke to the narrative that civilization arrived with the Anglos. Given that, the idea of erecting the ensemble, with public funds on public land, not in the distant past but in current memory, certainly seems like an act of aggression rather than commemoration.

The best part of every trip is realizing that it has upset your expectations

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×