Luggage to withstand airline handling

I have two favorite suitcases I use when needing checked luggage.  Both have similar construction, having a hard base and sides, but a soft expandable top.  Hence, they combine the protection of a hard suitcase for the most part, but offer the advantage of being somewhat expandable.  I wrap delicate purchases in laundry or a jacket, place near the hard base of the bag and without exception nothing has broken in transit (so far).  

One bag is also an Eagle Creek bag and the other is made by PacSafe.  Both bags are excellent.  The PacSafe bag has the advantage of being difficult for thieves to break into, but is slightly more expensive.

We alternate, depending on trip configuration, on two "soft" but not very 21" Delseys and a single 25" Swissgear of similar construction. They're all from a lower-price territory than Eagle Creek, but have worked well for us.

But my experience with the Swissgear has taught me to watch one thing I didn't think so important before: the wheels. The Delseys are a 'trolley' style with two wheels; they're easy to move over almost any terrain, even cobblestones. But the Swissgear is a 'spinner,' with four wheels, built too low to the ground to conveniently tilt and roll on two wheels as the trolleys do. Just fine on a marble airport floor. Nearly uncontrollable on all but the smoothest sidewalks!

PHeymont posted:

We alternate, depending on trip configuration, on two "soft" but not very 21" Delseys and a single 25" Swissgear of similar construction. They're all from a lower-price territory than Eagle Creek, but have worked well for us.

But my experience with the Swissgear has taught me to watch one thing I didn't think so important before: the wheels. The Delseys are a 'trolley' style with two wheels; they're easy to move over almost any terrain, even cobblestones. But the Swissgear is a 'spinner,' with four wheels, built too low to the ground to conveniently tilt and roll on two wheels as the trolleys do. Just fine on a marble airport floor. Nearly uncontrollable on all but the smoothest sidewalks!

Good point about the wheels.  It was while pulling a suitcase across cobblestones that I became devote to the trolley-style wheels.  Even Eagle Creek and Pacsafe bags can be purchased on sale or at discounted travel supply vendors.  Whatever you buy, be sure it is a well constructed bag with heavy duty zippers and latches that won't fall apart on you when you travel (which has happened to me with a cheaper duffel-style roller made by Sierra Design).

We bought a couple of sturdy Samsonite hard cases in 2003; one is still going strong, the other sadly passed away last year - after being bounced up several flights of stairs by a hotel porter in India. We were very disappointed with the two new Samsonite spinners we bought following this incident. Expensive, but quite flimsy. We have already had to put in warranty claims on both of them and I doubt whether they'll see much of 2018.

Professorabe posted:

We bought a couple of sturdy Samsonite hard cases in 2003; one is still going strong, the other sadly passed away last year - after being bounced up several flights of stairs by a hotel porter in India. We were very disappointed with the two new Samsonite spinners we bought following this incident. Expensive, but quite flimsy. We have already had to put in warranty claims on both of them and I doubt whether they'll see much of 2018.

Isn't is aggravating to get a new piece of luggage from a reputable company and it just isn't the quality of its 'ancestor'? I'm sorry to hear this, but glad they were under warranty.